THE
UNSPOKEN
Advait
pressed his forehead against the cool glass of the window. The train
slowed down and pulled into Nashik station, He was standing on this
platform after fifteen years. On the hot summer night of 10th
May with one bag and a rage he had left his city completely justified
at that time. Now he had come back with a suitcase, a head of greying
hair at forty-one, and a heavy feeling in his chest that he could not
name. His sister Aditi had called four days ago and told him that
their mother was not going to last the week. Her voice had been flat,
the way voices get when someone has been strong for too long.
"I
will be there," Advait said. There was a pause on the line. A
silence of fifteen years in it.
"Okay,"
Aditi said. Just that. Okay.
On
way home in the auto-rickshaw the thoughts of yesterday arrived in
succession. He watched the town pass by, some things remained and
some had changed. A big mall stood where the old cinema hall used to
be. A flyover cut across the road on which he had ridden his bicycle
as a boy. The lane to their house was unchanged, narrow, with
bougainvillea spilling over the compound wall of the Deshmukh house
next door. The red flowers looked too bright for a day like this. He
paused at his own gate for a moment before going in. This time the
house appeared smaller than he remembered. The paint had gone pale
and the garden his mother had attended every morning was still there,
but it was not that tidy now. He knocked, even though it was his
home. It was instinctively he did that. It just felt wrong to walk in
although he had spent his childhood there, but those fifteen years.
Aditi opened the door. She had cut her hair short and there were
lines around her eyes that had not been there the last time he had
seen her face on a video call three Diwalis ago. In person, she
looked tired and worn out.
"You
came," she said. "Of course I had to, " Advait was a
bit flustered.
She
stepped aside to let him in. The house still smelled the same.
Fifteen years and the smell had not changed, old wood and incense and
something that could only was his mother's cooking, all folded into a
single scent and that hit him deep.
"She's
sleeping," Aditi said. "The doctor had come in the
afternoon. He says maybe two, three days now." Advait just
nodded.
Putting
his bag down he followed Aditi to the kitchen. She heated up some dal
and rice without even asking him if he was hungry and put the plate
in front of him and sat across the table with a glass of water,
watching him eat the way their mother used to, making sure that they
actually finished. The hesitation of fifteen years clearly was
showing. They talked but nothing important. The weather, the auto
fare from the station and if the salt was ok in the dal. Small words
trying to fill a large space.
After
dinner, Aditi took him to his old room. She had put fresh sheets on
the bed. His old cricket posters were gone from the walls and the
room was clean and bare, like a guest room in a house. It looked like
a place that was not sure whether to remember the occupant or not.
"Get
some rest," she said from the doorway.
"Aditi,"
Advait said, looking at her.
"We
can talk tomorrow," she said. Not with anger, but with a firm
expression. He heard her door close. As he lay on the bed the ceiling
was the same one he had stared at as a teenager, lying awake with his
headphones, planning the life he was going to escape to. He had done
it and gone to Pune for college, then Mumbai for work, then further,
a career in urban planning which took him across the country. He had
built things. Roads, parks, housing projects that thousands of people
lived in now and had made a good life for himself, but his own house
was fractured.
He
had also made a lot of phone calls that were too short and a lot of
birthday messages that arrived a day late and a lot of reasons not to
come home.
At
two in the morning, finally he gave up on sleep and walked out into
the hallway. He stopped at his mother's door. It was ajar, he pushed
it gently and went in. She was lying on her back, very still, her
chest rising and falling slowly. The room was dark except for a small
lamp in the corner. She looked thin. Smaller than he had seen her
last. Her hair had turned completely white and her face showing with
age.
He
sat in the chair next to her bed, he did not touch her. He just sat
there, watching her breathe, something he had not done in fifteen
years. After a while, he got up and went back to the hallway.
That
was when he noticed the cupboard which was his father's old wooden
one that had always been there. His father had died three years ago.
A second heart attack. Advait had come for the funeral, stayed four
days, and left. He and Aditi had barely spoken even then.
The
bottom drawer of the cupboard was slightly open. Inside was an old
tin, it’s lid dented on one side. He remembered that his father
used to keep important papers in it. Reaching out he opened the tin.
Inside were letters. Not one or two, but a thick stack of them. It
was his father's handwriting, that particular slanting script, always
in blue ink. They were all addressed to Advait and none of them had
been posted. Some of them did not even have envelopes. They were just
folded papers, carefully dated, stacked by year.
His
hands were shaking as he unfolded the first one. It was from 2011.
The year after he had left home.
Advait,
I
heard from Suresh uncle that you got the job at the firm in Mumbai. I
am not going to pretend that I was not waiting to hear from you. Your
mother thinks I am still angry with you, but I am not. I don't know
what I am anymore. Maybe I was wrong about the engineering. Maybe I
was right. How does it matter now. I just want to know if you are ok.
That is all. Your mother doesn't sleep well.
Love
Baba.
Advait
sat down on the hallway floor, right there, back against the wall and
kept reading letter after letter.
His father had made
a list of him. Read
about a housing project in a magazine, a development in Navi Mumbai.
A journalist had mentioned the name of the young planner who had
designed the community park inside it. His father had torn the page
out and kept it. It was folded inside the letter.
I
showed this to your mother and she cried, but she told me not to tell
you that she cried.
His
father had a minor health scare. He didn't call Advait. He wrote a
letter instead, and then did not
send it.
I
thought about calling you, but decided against it. I did not want you
to leave your work and come. Also, I was afraid and what if you
wouldn't come. That would have been worse, That’s the reason I did
not even call you.
His
father had found Advait's Instagram, someone must have shown him how.
He wrote about a photo Advait had posted at a friend's wedding, in a
blue kurta, laughing at something outside the frame.
You
looked happy. That is the right word. Happy. I thought you would call
sometime. I thought I would call sometime. Neither of us ever did. I
don't know whose fault that is. Probably mine.
The
last letter was from March 2020 exactly Two years before he died.
Advait,
I
am getting older and I spend more time thinking about things I did
not say. I was never good at talking, even when you were small. My
father did not talk either, maybe that’s an excuse or it’s simply
true. Whatever it is but believe me I am proud of you. I should have
said it to you. I am saying it now. I am proud of you. The work you
do matters. You matter. Come home sometimes. Your mother misses you.
I miss you too, though I don't know how to say that out loud. I miss
you.
Advait
put the letter down on his lap. He pressed the back of his hand
against his mouth and sat very still, the way you do when something
is trying to break open inside you and at two in the morning and you
don't want to wake anyone. He sat like that for a long time and did
not hear Aditi come out of her room until she was standing right next
to him. She looked at the tin on the floor and the letters in his
hand. She had known about them long ago.
"You
knew," he said. She sat down on the floor beside him, back
against the wall, the way they used to sit as children, watching
cricket on the small TV in this same hallway when their parents
thought they were asleep.
"I
found them when I was going through his things," she said
quietly. "After the funeral. I read all of them."
"Why
didn't you tell me?" Advait had a lump in his throat.
She
was quiet for a moment. "I was not sure would it be ok to tell
you. Or maybe," She stopped. "Maybe I was angry."
"At
me." Advait said.
"At
you. At him. At all of it." She pulled her knees to her chest.
"He wrote letters to you for ten years and never sent a single
one. The things he could not say out loud. And you were the one who
had left. And yet you were the one he was writing to."
Advait
did not say anything because he could feel the unfairness of it, just
as she had felt it. The silence sat between them.
"I'm
sorry," he said resting his head on Aditi’s shoulder.
"You
don't have to be sorry for what you chose." She looked at the
wall ahead. "I am not angry anymore. I was, for a long time but
now I am just tired."
They
sat in the quiet hallway. The house breathed around them.
"You
never told me," he said slowly, "what happened here after I
left."
Aditi
looked at him. "It got harder. Baba's blood pressure. Then Aai
started having her knee trouble. The house needed fixing constantly.
I was working and managing everything at the same time. It was fine
and we were managing."
"You
gave up your plan," Advait said. "The Delhi one."
There was a deep silence and it was heavy.
"Where
did you hear that?" Her voice was careful.
"I
did not hear it from anyone. I just remembered, you had finished your
project and were waiting for a letter that summer. I left before it
came but after that I never asked what happened."
Aditi
was very still for a moment.
"I
had received a reply for the Social Sciences program," she said.
“It
was a good college."
"You
didn't go."
"No."
The
“NO” sat between them, small and heavy as stone.
"Aditi,"
"Don't."
Her voice was soft but clear. "Don't say sorry again. There's
nothing to apologise for. I had made a choice and I could have gone,
but I chose not to." She looked at him in the eye for the first
time since they had sat down. "Aai and Baba were not helpless.
They would have managed but I just, did not go when I looked at that
letter and thought that if I also leave, then who holds this place?
Who stays?" She gave a small smile.
"Foolish,
maybe."
"Not
foolish," Advait said.
"No.
Not foolish. Just, what I was." She paused. "What I decided
to be."
Advait
was now shaking from inside and was feeling bad about her. In spite
of so much she had endured and sacrificed she was not bitter and she
never complained. But now he could feel her pain. He thought about
his own years, the freedom and the choice of making his life. All
this time he thought that leaving the house is a kind of courage but
he was wrong. Staying without freedom was a bigger courage. Both of
them were living their choices.
"I
should have called more," he said.
"Yes."
"I
should have come back more often."
"Yes."
"I
think," he started, then stopped. He tried again. "I think
I was afraid of this house, afraid of the feeling I had inside me.
Afraid that staying in a small town would dwarf me and my potential.
I thought if I stayed away long enough, the thoughts would stop
following me."
"Did
it?"
"No,"
he said. "I just carried it somewhere else and labelled it
freedom."
A
small sound came from their mother's room. A shift in the bed. Both
of them went very still and listened. Nothing followed. She was still
sleeping.
"She
talked about you all the time," Aditi said quietly. "Even
when she was pretending not to. She had see something on the news,
some new road or overpass, and she would say, that's the kind of
thing your brother does."
Advait
closed his eyes.
Aditi
said. "She missed you terribly and she was proud of you. Both
feelings, at the same time. That was very much her."
"And
Baba? What did he say? What were his words?"
Aditi
thought about it. "Nothing directly. But sometimes in the
evenings, when there was nothing on TV, he would step into your room
and look at your photo and just say your name - Advait. Just the
name. And then nothing after it. As if saying it out loud was
enough."
That
was the thing that finally broke the dam, not the unsent words on
paper, but this. His name, said into a quiet room, as a complete
sentence in itself. His father in his old chair, saying his son's
name the way you say the name of something precious that you are not
sure how to hold.
Advait
leaned his head back against the wall. The tears came and trickled
down his cheeks. Aditi did not react or put her hand on his shoulder.
She simply stayed there beside him and allowed the fifteen years to
flow.
When
Advait was done, she got up without a word and came back from the
kitchen with two cups of chai and sat down on the floor beside him.
The sips were the only sound at that time. The chai was too sweet,
Aditi had always liked more sugar than anyone else in this family.
Advait did not say anything about it, it tasted exactly right.
"I
will come back more," he said. "After everything. I will
actually come back."
Aditi
looked at her cup. "You can stay for a while now, if you want.
There's no hurry to leave."
It
was an offering which he took.
"Okay,"
he said.
Advait
was on one side of the bed, Aditi on the other. Her breathing had
been slow all night, growing softer. And then, somewhere in that
golden early hour, it simply stopped. There was no struggle. She
looked peaceful and they were holding their mother's hand while she
was leaving for her final journey. She had a light smile on her face
as if she knew something they did not.
The
room was very quiet. Aditi pressed her mother's hand to her cheek and
held it there. Advait stayed where he was. Neither of them spoke for
a long time.
Later,
when the phone calls had been made and the neighbours had come and
the house had filled with noise and the movements, Advait stepped out
into the garden alone.
He
stood there and looked at it. The bougainvillea from the Deshmukh
house had spread further over the wall. And along the fence, in a
corner a bunch of small white flowers, his mother's jasmine was in
full bloom. He had not noticed it last night. It must have just
opened.
He
stood still and thought about all the things that don't get said
between people. Not because the feeling isn't there, but because
feeling something and saying it out loud are two completely different
abilities, and some families never manage to build both. His father
had written it all down and kept it in a tin. His mother had
expressed it through quiet pride. Aditi had expressed it by simply
not leaving. And he had expressed nothing at all, just gone, and kept
going, and told himself that was a life.
All
of them loving each other in their own language which they knew which
wasn't enough. And all of them knowing it wasn't enough. And none of
them knowing how to learn another.
He
heard the door open behind him. Aditi came and stood next to him.
They looked at the jasmine together.
"She
planted that along the fence the year I was born," Aditi said.
"She told me once, years ago. I don't think she ever told you."
"No,"
Advait said. "There's a lot we didn't know about each other."
"Yes,"
she said.
They
stood there in the morning, close enough that their shoulders were
almost touching. Two people who had grown up under the same roof,
breathing the same air, eating at the same table, and had somehow,
across the years, through silence and distance and all the things
that went unsaid, become strangers to each other. Not through cruelty
but
just
through the slow, quiet drifting that happens when no one ever says
wait,
stop, I need to tell you something.
But
now, in the light of this morning, with their mother just gone and
their father's letters still on the hallway floor where Advait had
left them the night before, they were finding their way back.
Not
with big speeches nor with explanations or apologies and not trying
to cover the fifteen years in one go.
Just
standing in the garden. Beside each other. Finally, after all this
time, not looking away.
The
jasmine moved very slightly in the morning air as
if acknowledging the new found connection.